The details of how Caryma Sa’d allegedly convinced Jeremy Mackenzie to go undercover for the RCMP remain speculative, but several factors likely contributed to her ability to pull off such a stunning coup.

1. Leverage Over Legal Battles

Mackenzie has faced a slew of legal challenges in recent years, including charges related to firearms offenses, hate speech, and threats of violence. These charges put significant pressure on Mackenzie, and it's possible that Sa’d, a seasoned lawyer, saw an opportunity to exploit this vulnerability. By leveraging his precarious legal situation, she could have presented the option of cooperating with law enforcement as a way to mitigate the legal consequences. It’s not uncommon for informants to be motivated by the promise of reduced sentences or even immunity from prosecution, particularly when they face long-term incarceration or significant fines.

2. Psychological Persuasion

Sa’d, known for her sharp wit and often biting critique of her enemies, likely used a mix of psychological manipulation and strategic framing to convince Mackenzie that working with the RCMP could be in his best interest. She might have framed the deal not as a betrayal of his movement but as a tactical retreat or strategic maneuver that could buy him time, resources, or favor within certain powerful circles.

By presenting Mackenzie with a scenario in which he could still maintain influence — or even bolster his status by appearing to play the system — Sa’d could have appealed to his sense of self-preservation while masking the nature of the cooperation. This kind of psychological game, appealing to Mackenzie's ego or survival instincts, might have played a role in bringing him to the table.

3. Shared Understanding of Extremism

Sa’d and Mackenzie both understand the dynamics of extremism and its influence in the current political climate. Sa’d has spent considerable time engaging with far-right figures, often attending rallies and protests where individuals like Mackenzie and his followers congregate. This gave her an intimate understanding of the mindset of such groups, which could have enabled her to craft a message that resonated with Mackenzie.

By positioning herself as someone who understands his frustrations with the system, Sa’d might have gained his trust over time. She could have sold the idea that working with law enforcement didn’t have to be a complete betrayal of his values but rather a way to keep himself relevant while buying time to regroup or even influence the RCMP's actions from within.

4. Promise of Protection

Another angle Sa’d may have used is the promise of safety. The far-right ecosystem is notoriously unstable, with internal power struggles and factional in-fighting. Mackenzie, as a prominent figure, could easily become a target from within his own ranks, particularly if his leadership or loyalty is questioned. Sa’d, leveraging her experience as a lawyer, might have convinced him that cooperating with the RCMP could offer him some form of protection from both legal and physical threats, especially if his own followers or rival groups began to turn on him.

5. Exploiting Fatigue and Disillusionment

Mackenzie’s involvement in the far-right movement may have taken a personal toll, particularly given the ongoing legal battles and the pressure of maintaining a leadership role in a movement that often operates at the fringes of legality. Sa’d, keenly aware of these stresses, could have capitalized on any signs of fatigue, offering Mackenzie an exit strategy disguised as cooperation.

If Mackenzie had grown disillusioned with the movement's direction or realized he was in over his head, Sa’d could have framed the RCMP collaboration as a way to step back without fully abandoning his principles. This approach might have resonated if Mackenzie felt he had few other options left.

Conclusion

In sum, it’s likely that Caryma Sa’d used a combination of legal leverage, psychological insight, and strategic positioning to convince Jeremy Mackenzie to cooperate with the RCMP. By offering him a lifeline amid his mounting legal woes and appealing to his instincts for self-preservation, she may have orchestrated what could become one of the most significant turns in Canada’s battle against far-right extremism.